HUANG Jin-liang 1, XU Xin-gang2, WU Bing-fang1. Preliminary Comparison of Various Agricultural Information from Different Sources[J]. Journal of Remote Sensing, 2004, (6): 655-663. DOI: 10.11834/jrs.20040616.
Preliminary Comparison of Various Agricultural Information from Different Sources
Agricultural information is various and from different sources
such as remote sensing monitoring
statistic data
market research
meteorological information
and in-situ measurement. These data distribute dispersedly in different government departments or units
and lack mutual exchange and validation
comprehensive analysis and organic integration. In order to take advantage of various kinds of data
comprehensive analysis should be strengthened. In this paper
agricultural information from various sources
such as cropland acreage
crop acreage
crop yield
crop growth and grain yield
is compared and analyzed preliminarily on the aspect of content and expression fashion
and statistic approach and so on. Compared agricultural information by remote sensing with other information
cropland acreage by remote sensing is accurate and credible. Crop growth monitored by remote sensing is much more direct and comprehensive. Crop acreage by remote sensing is larger than that by statistic data(statistic crop acreage maybe lesser). Crop yield of per units estimated by remote sensing is lower than statistic data(statistic data maybe higher). Crop yield estimated by remote sensing is approaching relatively to statistic data
but there is still difference. Crop yield estimated by remote sensing maybe higher
and by statistic data maybe lower . Through comparison of various agricultural information from different sources
it is affirmative that agricultural information by remote sensing has advantages in objectivity
spatio-temporal continuity
comparability
forecast-ability and lower cost. On the other hand
agricultural information by remote sensing has deficiency and localization. Though analysis in this paper it is indicated that both remote sensing information and other information are valuable in existence
and their accuracy need be enhanced. Different agricultural information could not be substituted they are complementary and validated for each other. In order to reflect agricultural circumstances more entirely and exactly
agricultural information from different sources should be comprehensively analyzed and integrated.