Comparison of global albedo products of MODIS V006 and V005 based on FLUXNET

Zhiming FENG; Jianguang WEN; Qing XIAO; Dongqin YOU; Xingwen LIN; Xiaodan WU

doi:10.11834/jrs.20186427

Technology and Methodology | Views : 0 下载量: 540 CSCD: 5

PDF
Export
Share
Collection
Album

Comparison of global albedo products of MODIS V006 and V005 based on FLUXNET
Vol. 22, Issue 1, Pages: 97-109(2018)
Received：23 November 2016，

Accepted：09 March 2017，

Published：2018-01
DOI： 10.11834/jrs.20186427
稿件说明：

移动端阅览

冯智明, 闻建光, 肖青, 游冬琴, 林兴稳, 吴小丹. 2018. MODIS V006和V005全球反照率产品精度对比分析. 遥感学报, 22(1): 97–109 DOI： 10.11834/jrs.20186427.

Feng Z M, Wen J G, Xiao Q, You D Q, Lin X W and Wu X D. 2018. Comparison of global albedo products of MODIS V006 and V005 based on FLUXNET. Journal of Remote Sensing, 22(1): 97–109 DOI： 10.11834/jrs.20186427.

摘要

反照率作为一种非常重要的地表能量平衡、全球变化研究的参数，在众多研究领域中得到了广泛的应用，到目前为止已经有多种全球范围的反照率产品进行业务化生产和发布，针对不同反照率产品质量评价的研究也变得愈加重要。MODLAND团队在MODIS V005反照率产品反演算法的基础上通过改进16天周期内观测数据加权的方法生产出新版本的反照率产品MODIS V006。本文针对MODIS两个版本V005及V006的反照率产品，利用FLUXNET地面站点数据，比较验证两个版本反照率的总体精度以及在不同地表类型条件下的精度差异，同时通过交叉验证的方法分析二者的差异及稳定性。验证结果表明，MODIS V006反照率产品虽然在全反演高质量的数据比例上较V005有所下降，但是在同等条件下V006在提高时间分辨率的同时其精度也有所提高，在不同的地表类型条件下精度也优于V005，且在时间序列分布上具有稳定比例的高质量数据，可以满足大多数应用的精度需求。

Abstract

Land surface albedos represent an important parameter in the Earth’s energy balance

and they play a crucial role in the global change and climate systems. Numerous global or regional land surface albedo products with various spatial resolutions and temporal frequencies have been released. Thus

the quality analysis of albedo products has become increasingly important. On the basis of the algorithm of a version 5 albedo product (MODIS V005)

a new daily product version (MODIS V006) with a high temporal resolution is generated with MODLAND. The new albedo product requires urgent validation

and its accuracy should be known before extensive use. On the basis of sites with adequate spatial representativeness in the FLUXNET network

direct comparisons between different versions of albedo products and

in situ

albedos were conducted. To investigate the accuracy under various land cover type conditions of the two versions of albedo products

we divided the ground measurements into six classes and calculated several evaluation indicators. Two different versions of products were also compared using a cross-validation method under the prior knowledge that V005 has been extensively estimated and that the method achieves good performance in various validation works. At the same time

the Quality Control (QC) flag was investigated to analyze the stability of the new albedo products. The direct comparison results indicate that two versions of products show good consistency against the

in situ

albedos. However

V006 performs better than V005 during the same experimental time. For the accuracy under different land cover types

all the evaluation indicators briefly show that V006 products achieve a better match with

in situ

albedos than V005 products. As the V006 has a high temporal resolution

accurately capturing the rapid changes of land surface albedos is relatively easy

especially during snow-covered days. The comparison result obtained through the cross-validation method indicates that except for a few slightly high values

the V006 product effectively matches the V005 product. Although the percentage of QC flag indicating the good quality of the V006 product is lower than that of the V005 product

data show the stable performance of both products in the span of three years. The MODIS V006 product has a shorter temporal resolution and higher accuracy than the V005 product. The trends of the two albedo products over the time series highlight their good consistency. However

V006 performs better than MODIS V005 during snow-covered times. This finding is expected to play a significant role in many other research fields.

关键词

Keywords

references

Bacour C and Bréon F M. 2005. Variability of biome reflectance directional signatures as seen by POLDER. Remote Sensing of Environment, 98(1): 80–95

Cescatti A, Marcolla B, Vannan S K S, Pan J Y, Román M O, Yang X Y, Ciais P, Cook R B, Law B E, Matteucci G, Migliavacca M, Moors E, Richardson A D, Seufert G and Schaaf C B. 2012. Intercomparison of MODIS albedo retrievals and in situ measurements across the global FLUXNET network. Remote Sensing of Environment, 121: 323–334

Dickinson R E. 1983. Land surface processes and climate—Surface albedos and energy balance. Advances in Geophysics, 25: 305–353

姜小光, 李召良, 习晓环, 李显彬, 李子扬. 2008. 遥感真实性检验系统框架初步构想. 干旱区地理, 31(4): 567–571

Jiang X G, Li Z L, Xi X H, Li X B and Li Z Y. 2008. Basic frame of remote sensing validation system. Arid Land Geography, 31(4): 567–571 (

焦子锑, 王锦地, 谢里欧, 张颢, 阎广建, 何立明, 李小文. 2005. 地面和机载多角度观测数据的反照率反演及对MODIS反照率产品的初步验证. 遥感学报, 9(1): 64–72

Jiao Z T, Wang J D, Xie L O, Zhang H, Yan G J, He L M and Li X W. 2005. Initial Validation of MODIS albedo product by using field measurements and airborne multiangular remote sensing observations. Journal of Remote Sensing, 9(1): 64–72 (

Justice C, Belward A, Morisette J, Lewis P, Privette J and Baret F. 2000. Developments in the ‘validation’ of satellite sensor products for the study of the land surface. International Journal of Remote Sensing, 21(17): 3383–3390

Leroy M, Deuzé J L, Bréon F M, Hautecoeur O, Herman M, Buriez J C, Tanré D, Bouffiès S, Chazette P and Roujean J L. 1997. Retrieval of atmospheric properties and surface bidirectional reflectances over land from POLDER/ADEOS. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 102(D14): 17023–17037

Lewis P, Brockmann C, Danne O, Fischer J, Guanter L, Heckel A, Krueger O, López G, Muller J and North P. 2011. GlobAlbedo algorithm theoretical basis document: version 3.0.

Lewis P, Guanter L, Saldana G L, Muller J P, Watson G, Shane N, Kennedy T, Fisher J, Domenech C, Preusker R, North P, Heckel A, Danne O, Krämer U, Zühlke M, Fomferra N, Brockmann C and Schaaf C. 2012. The ESA globAlbedo project: algorithm//2012 IEEE International Geoscience and Remote Sensing Symposium. Munich, Germany: IEEE [DOI: 10.1109/IGARSS.2012.6352306]

梁顺林. 2009. 定量遥感. 范闻捷, 译. 北京: 科学出版社

Liang S L. 2009. Quantitative remote sensing of land surfaces. Fan W J, trans. Beijing: Science Press.

Liang S L, Zhao X, Liu S H, Yuan W P, Cheng X, Xiao Z Q, Zhang X T, Liu Q, Cheng J, Tang H R, Qu Y H, Bo Y C, Qu Y, Ren H Z, Yu K and Townshend J. 2013. A long-term Global LAnd Surface Satellite (GLASS) data-set for environmental studies. International Journal of Digital Earth, 6(S1): 5–33

Liu Q, Wang L Z, Qu Y, Liu N F, Liu S H, Tang H R and Liang S L. 2013. Preliminary evaluation of the long-term GLASS albedo product. International Journal of Digital Earth, 6(S1): 69–95

Lucht W, Schaaf C B and Strahler A H. 2000. An algorithm for the retrieval of albedo from space using semiempirical BRDF models. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 38(2): 977–998

Privette J L, Eck T F and Deering D W. 1997. Estimating spectral albedo and nadir reflectance through inversion of simple BRDF models with AVHRR/MODIS-like data. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 102(D24): 29529–29542

Roman M O, Gatebe C K, Shuai Y M, Wang Z S, Gao F, Masek J G, He T, Liang S L and Schaaf C B. 2013. Use of in situ and airborne multiangle data to assess MODIS-and landsat-based estimates of directional reflectance and albedo. IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 51(3): 1393–1404

Román M O, Schaaf C B, Woodcock C E, Strahler A H, Yang X Y, Braswell R H, Curtis P S, Davis K J, Dragoni D, Goulden M L, Gu L H, Hollinger D Y, Kolb T E, Meyers T P, Munger J W, Privette J L and Richardson A D. 2009. The MODIS (Collection V005) BRDF/albedo product: assessment of spatial representativeness over forested landscapes. Remote Sensing of Environment, 113(11): 2476–2498

Roujean J L, Leroy M and Deschamps P Y. 1992. A bidirectional reflectance model of the Earth’s surface for the correction of remote sensing data. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmosphere, 97(D18): 20455–20468

Schaaf C B, Gao F, Strahler A H, Lucht W, Li X W, Tsang T, Strugnell N C, Zhang X Y, Jin Y F,Muller J P, Lewis P, Barnsley M, Hobson P, Disney M, Roberts G, Dunderdale M, Doll C, d’Entremont R P, Hu B X, Liang S L, Privette J L and Roy D. 2002. First operational BRDF, albedo nadir reflectance products from MODIS. Remote Sensing of Environment, 83(1/2): 135–148

Wang K C, Liang S L, Schaaf C L and Strahler A H. 2010. Evaluation of Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer land surface visible and shortwave albedo products at FLUXNET sites. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmosphere, 115(D17): D17107

Wang Z S, Schaaf C B, Strahler A H, Chopping M J, Román M O, Shuai Y M, Woodcock C E, Hollinger D Y and Fitzjarrald D R. 2014. Evaluation of MODIS albedo product (MCD43A) over grassland, agriculture and forest surface types during dormant and snow-covered periods. Remote Sensing of Environment, 140: 60–77

Wanner W, Li X and Strahler A H. 1995. On the derivation of kernels for kernel‐driven models of bidirectional reflectance. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 100(D10): 21077–21089

Wanner W, Strahler A H, Hu B, Lewis P, Muller J P, Li X, Schaaf C L B and Barnsley M J. 1997. Global retrieval of bidirectional reflectance and albedo over land from EOS MODIS and MISR data: theory and algorithm. Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 102(D14): 17143–17161

闻建光, 刘强, 柳钦火, 肖青, 李小文. 2015. 陆表二向反射特性遥感建模及反照率反演. 北京: 科学出版社

Wen J G, Liu Q, Liu Q H, Xiao Q and Li X W. 2015. Land surface bidirectional reflectance characteristics of remote sensing modeling and albedo inversion. Beijing: Science Press.

吴小丹, 闻建光, 肖青, 李新, 刘强, 唐勇, 窦宝成, 彭菁菁, 游冬琴, 李小文. 2015. 关键陆表参数遥感产品真实性检验方法研究进展. 遥感学报, 19(1): 75–92

Wu X D, Wen J G, Xiao Q, Li X, Liu Q, Tang Y, Dou B C, Peng J J, You D Q and Li X W. 2015. Advances in validation methods for remote sensing products of land surface parameters. Journal of Remote Sensing, 19(1): 75–92 (

吴小丹, 肖青, 闻建光, 刘强, 彭菁菁, 李小文. 2014. 遥感数据产品真实性检验不确定性分析研究进展. 遥感学报, 18(5): 1011–1023

Wu X D, Xiao Q, Wen J G, Liu Q, Peng J J and Li X W. 2014. Advances in uncertainty analysis for the validation of remote sensing products: take leaf area index for example. Journal of Remote Sensing, 18(5): 1011–1023 (

Zhang R H, Tian J, Li Z L, Su H B, Chen S H and Tang X Z. 2010. Principles and methods for the validation of quantitative remote sensing products. Science China Earth Sciences, 53(5): 741–751

Alert me when the article has been cited

提交

Spatial reconstruction-aided spatio-temporal fusion of NDVI images

Common mistakes in remote sensing studies of green tides and golden tides in the Yellow Sea and East China Sea

Monitoring chilling damage of corn in the Northeast China based on MODIS LST and meteorological data

Machine learning-based mapping of fraction snow cover in High Mountain Asia by MODIS